Independent Governance Group
Telephone
T: +44 (0)20 4599 7299
E: info@weareigg.com
Search
  • Professional Trusteeship
  • Our Services
  • Our Team
  • About Us
  • Culture & Values
  • News & Views
  • Case Studies
  • Careers
  • Useful Links
  • Contact Us

Case Studies

Difficult valuation exercise

02 February 2023

Context

A UK oil company, part of a privately owned multinational parent, had a hybrid DB/DC scheme with assets of c.£150m. The deficit had increased and the sponsor’s covenant was weak as whilst it had oil and gas assets in the UK, there was considerable risk around future cashflows due to volatility in the oil and gas prices, the expected life of the fields they owned, and future de-commissioning costs which would outweigh revenue over time.

The challenge

There was no Parent Company Guarantee (PCG) and there was no visibility of the overseas parent’s assets. The Sponsor considered it was in a strong position due to its revenue-generating capacity and was unwilling to provide any form of contingent asset to support the scheme. Due to the cash pooling arrangements in place the, Trustee was not confident in being able to access the cash sitting on the balance sheet in times of stress.

Our approach

The existing trustees could see the problem but were struggling to see a solution. Our approach was to design a funding plan to increase contributions but fixed on a solvency basis tied to the life of the fields. This new funding plan incorporated an extended recovery period and payment of substantial sums to cover s75 debt.

It was critical to finding a solution where the covenant was considered in the context of the period over which the Company would be cash flow positive rather than purely the Company balance sheet.

The outcomes

The de-risking strategy for the scheme was revised to align to the new funding plan so that within 10 years, the scheme should have all assets in matching assets ready to buy-out. Over the 18-month timescale of negotiation, there had been a substantial amount of transfers from the DB section of the scheme, c.20% of liabilities between the valuation date and settlement date, which the Trustee was able to allow for when settling on the level of contributions required.

 

What's New?

13 May 2025

Helping with the challenges of running a DB scheme

How we encouraged innovative and collaborative solutions to overcome conflict between key stakeholders.

READ MORE

30 Apr 2025

How to do four buy-ins in four months

In just four months, the PACE pension scheme de-risked over £2.75bn of liabilities through a series of swift buy-in transactions, enabled by proactive governance and market agility despite the onset of Covid-19.

READ MORE

23 Apr 2025

Small Scheme Bulk Annuity Purchase

Working with our wider adviser contacts and their consolidation services offering we successfully completed a buy-in December 2019, moving to full buy-out in February 2020.

READ MORE

QUICK LINKS

  • Professional Trusteeship
  • Our Services
  • Team
  • About Us
  • News & Views
  • Careers
  • Useful Links
  • Contact Us
  • PPF Trustmark
  • Data Privacy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Equality, Diversity, Inclusion
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Modern Day Slavery Statement

ADDRESS

4th Floor Cannon Place
78 Cannon Street
London
EC4N 6HL

CONTACT

T: +44 (0)20 4599 7299
E: info@weareigg.com

LinkedIn

Independent Governance Group ("IGG") is the trading name of Ross Trustees Services Limited (07904277), Independent Trustee Services Limited (02567540), Independent Trustee Limited (02473669), Clarity Trustees Limited (12470917), Leadenhall Independent Trustees Limited (02303944) all registered in England and Wales. Registered office address: 4th Floor Cannon Place, 78 Cannon Street, London EC4N 6HL. IC Select Limited (SC331180). Registered office address: DWF LLP, 103 Waterloo Street, Glasgow G2 7BW.

© 2025 Hamsard 3776 Limited, Ross Trustees Services Limited & Independent Trustee Services Limited. All Rights Reserved.

We are audited annually as set out in the Relevant Trustee Supplement to ICAEW AAF 02/07 to support our inclusion in the TPR’s Independent Trustee Register.

SIGN UP

Notifications

Mailing list

  • To be added to our mailing list, please provide the following information:

  • When you submit this form, the personal data provided will be used to respond to your query and to provide information to you about what we do and how we do it. We will hold the personal data you provide securely and may send you information in the future about our services. You will always have the opportunity to opt out of receiving any further communications from us.

    If you wish to know more about how we process your personal data and understand your rights, please see our Data Privacy statement.